THE DARK HOURS

March 2005

 

Starring:  Kate Greenhouse, Aidan Devine, Gordon Currie and Iris Graham

 

Directed by:  Paul Fox

 

Screenplay:  Wil Zmak

 

This is not a horror movie.  It is a Horror Filym.

 

This was Paul Fox's directorial debut and is a fantastic horror flick.  It has won awards all over the world and is sure to become a favourite among horror lovers everywhere.  In it, Kate Greenhouse plays a doctor, Samantha, who is suffering from an inoperable brain tumor.  Gordon Vurrie plays her husband, David, a writer and Iris Graham plays Greenhouse's younger sister, Melody, who has dropped out of university and now freeloads off Samantha and David, ostensibly as David's assistant.  Samantha works at a high end psychiatric hospital treating the criminally insane.  On the day she finds out that her tumor is growing and will soon kill her.  She calls David to see if they can get away for the weekend.  He informs her that he is spending the weekend at their isolated cabin (with Melody) in order to finish his most recent novel but that he and Samantha will get away some weekend soon.  Not wanting to discuss her problems over the phone Samantha drives to the cabin to talk to her husband and her sister.  While there the three of them are confronted and held hostage by a psychotic patient of Samantha's (played extremely well by Aidan Devine) who obviously feels that he has been mistreated by her.  He has more than a few "issues" and makes the family play violent and sick games to torture them into believing what he considers is the truth.  

IF YOU HAVE NOT YET WATCHED THIS MOVIE I WOULD ADVISE THAT YOU STOP READING HERE.

In this movie there is tension almost from the first shot and the tension keeps building the whole way through. However, the plot I have outlined above is not really the plot.  This is one of those mind-fuck movies where, by the end of the last scene, you are not certain what was real and what wasn't.  As a mind-fuck movie of this sort (think The Usual Suspects meets When a Stranger Calls) there were, in my opinion, some issues with what may or may not have been "real".  

I know there is a lot of problems with even questioning what is "real" in a movie but I like my fantasies to have a strong logical rationale.  

By the end of this movie the viewer is left with a lot of information to re-digest and try to put in order and I felt that a few things did not logically follow no matter how I dealt with them. Maybe this simply adds to the confusion and heightens the experience for some but, for me, it left me wondering how I would have fixed it.  

I also made the mistake of watching the "Alternate Ending" available on the DVD (without the Director's commentary) and, with the alternate ending it was (fairly) evident that basically the whole movie was an invention of Samantha's troubled imagination.  On the other hand, the ending that was chosen for the movie left things much more up in the air (and was the better of the two).  You see, the psychopath is a figment of Samantha's imagination.  Presumably he is (as he says he is) a prisoner that she had done illegal and unethical drug experiments on with the hope of finding a cure for her own tumor.  He leads her through a sick series of physical and psychological horrors to bring her to the understanding that (a) she was wrong to test drugs on him and (b) that she actually arrived at the cabin, caught her husband banging her sister and killed them both with an axe. Then, after killing the family dog, she cuts off one of her own fingers, realizes that the psychotic guy is imaginary, locks herself in the bathroom and sends herself into a coma using the drug she had tested on the psychopath and that she has been taking all along (making us question the veracity of any of her observations right from the beginning of the movie).

Or maybe she doesn't kill anyone and has just imagined the whole thing as some sort of self-induced punishment for her illegal actions with the drug tests.  Or maybe the drugs have caused the hallucinations.  Or maybe when her husband is acting like he might be having an affair with the little sister she snaps, goes into shock and spends the entire movie lying on the bathroom floor imagining what we are watching.

It is difficult to tell what the "real" story was in this movie.  What is not difficult to tell is that every level of reality is done with superb craftsmanship. The film has a dark, panicked quality to it that works.  It lacks the goofball self-satire that too many horror movies (or any movies) have these days.  The Characters also have a depth that one doesn't get to see in horror films anymore (imagine heightening the experience by making us care about the characters - who would have thought?).  Unlike hack and slash horror movies, we are invested in the outcome. The directing is great and the story astounds, horrifies and captures the audience.  On top of this the few special effects that were necessary were brilliant, the acting was superb and the story was brutally captivating.

It is probably not important that, in the end, I am not certain the story made sense overall - the fact that it didn't (or maynot have) bugs me and that just makes me like the film more.

Go rent it.