CASABLANCA
Staring:
Humphrey Bogart, Ingrid Bergman, Claude Rains and Paul Henreid
Released in January 1942
Directed by Michael Cutiz
Originally written for stage by Murray Burnett and Joan Alison. Adapted for Screen by Julius J. Epstein, Philip G. Epstein and Hugo W. Friedhofer.
This movie is definitely one of the greatest of all time. Maybe it is not so great because of what a great movie it is but because of how many people have seen it and believe it to be great. The accepted plot is thus: Rick was a good guy who became disillusioned in the searly part of the World War II when the woman he loved deserted him just as they were about to flee Paris with the German invasion forces moments away. Rick ends up in Casablanca (part of unoccupied France), owning a Club that caters mostly to travellers looking to secure passage to America, drink, gamble and listen to good music. Rick, once a fighter for the underdog, is now neutral in all his dealings and does not wish to get involved. Then, one day, his true love enters the bar with an important rebel leader. It turns out that these two are married. Rick has recently come into possession of some premium false papers and can get two people to America but will not do it for these two as he is still feeling the pain of being deserted back in France. His ex-girlfriends pleads with him, then threatens him at gunpoint and finally admits that she loves him and she will stay if only he will send her husband to freedom. Then her husband says he will stay if only Rick will escape with (and save) the girl. Rick tricks everyone, and gets his ex and her husand on a plane headed for freedom. It is near the end that I think it breaks down.
Before you beat me senseless let me explain. It seems to be accepted that his ex, Ilas, genuinely falls in love with Rick again just after he calls her bluff when she threatens to shoot him. I personally do not think that enough was done to demonstrate that this was real love and not just a ploy to save her husband. In fact, if it was a ploy to save her husband then, moments later, when her husband asks Rick to leave with Isla to save her, it would make sense that Rick, realizing how much these two mean to each other, would put them on the plane together. If Ilsa really loves Rick and Rick believes her then I fail to see what motivates him to put her on the Plane with her husband. Oh. I know. There are a plethora of possibile answers for this, but none of them are supported by the movie. He could, for example, feel she is better off with her husband, but there is nothing in the movie that suggests this. Rick could feel that her husband will not be the rebel leader that he is without her and Rick could decide that the Rebel leader is more impartant than him. There is nothing in the movie to support this. He could have felt that Ilas was willing to sacrafice herself for her husband and vice versa and that this is reason enough to sacrafice him-self to the cause of true love. There is, I think, some evidence for this in the movie. To begin with he helps out a brunette hotty and her husband by cheating at his own roulette tables so that the husband can pay the police bribe with money and the wife doesn't have to pay it with romance. Moreover, his "hill of beans" speech to Ilsa would seem to suggest that his life is no longer that important in the grander scheme of things. There is, however, as far as I can tell, nothing to support Rick putting Ilsa on the plane with her husband when it benefits only her husband. Nothing, that is, except for the general consensus that this is exactly what Rick does.
I guess I am not saying that the usual interpretation is incorrect. I am not saying that the alternate interpretation I have provided is correct. What I find with this movie, however, is that there is not enough there to let me firmly decide what actually happens at the end. Maybe Ilsa falls back in love with Rick to the eclusion of her husband. Maybe Isla lies to Rick to save her husband. Maybe her husband, by suggesting to Rick that he run off and save Ilsa proves to Rick that the husband is the bigger man and is what is best for Ilsa. I don't think anyone can say for certain even if everyone does seem to say for certain.
Oh. And Rick never says "Play it again sam". he does, however, say cool things like "I remeber every detail [about our last night together], the Germans wore grey, you wore blue."
It is a damn good movie.